America.gov's New AI: 4 Lessons for Designers

I asked the government's new AI what to eat, four ways. Four very different answers. One is a template you can copy.

Design review11 minUser research

The America.gov logo, a small American flag beside the wordmark The template
The fourth answer is the one to copy: what I can't do, why, what I can do instead, and where to go.
The question

What does your AI say when it can't help?

Done this kind of thing before? Trying it yourself.

Try it yourself

Write the prompt sheet and the "no" for your own AI

Here's the goal. Hand it to Claude or any AI and work it out. The steps below open on a hint if you get stuck.

The goal
A two-column prompt sheet from your real data, and a four-part reply for something your AI can't do.
Time
About 10 minutes to draft
Starter prompt · any AI
I'm designing an AI assistant for [my product]. Make me a two-column sheet. Column A: the 20 most common real questions, from [search logs, support tickets and call-center data]. Column B: how a stressed person would actually type each one. Then write the reply for a question my assistant can't answer: what it can't do, why, what it can do instead, and where to go.

Check your result

  • Column B sounds like a stressed person, not a product manager
  • The "no" says what you can't do and why
  • It ends with what you can do instead and where to go

Step 1

Start from user needs

Lesson 1: Start from user needs

America.gov puts a big prompt box on the landing page and cycles it through real situations: "I just got married, how do I change my name?" It starts from the citizen's pain point, not from a list of services. That teaches people how to ask, not just what to ask about.

USA.gov took the same route in its 2017 redesign, shifting from agency-centric to task-oriented, starting from search logs and call-center questions. For your own product, make a sheet:

Column A: the 20 most common real questions, from search logs, support tickets and call-center data. Column B: how a stressed person would actually type their question.
Column A is your data. Column B is how a person really types it.

Then test your longest language, like German, and your narrowest screen. America.gov scrolls long prompts in a marquee so the cropped text stays readable.

Test your longest language, for example German, and your narrowest screen

Step 2

Trust that people can check

Lesson 2: Trust that people can check

Tap Sources and America.gov lists the agencies behind the answer, with the article titles. For one query, CMS.gov alone listed eight articles. You can open them and cross-check the answer.

Next level: add a last-updated date. Then people can spot an outdated article, and fresher sources can rank higher.

Step 3

Test the edge case

Lesson 3: Test the edge case

I asked what to eat four ways. The first two got a one-line no. The third gave generic advice, with links I couldn't open. The fourth is the one to copy.

The response template
What I can't do → why → what I can do instead → where to go
The fourth answer, annotated: what I can do instead, what I cannot do and why, where to go, and suggested next steps
The fourth answer, annotated.

It said it helps with official U.S. government information and services (what it can do), not daily meal ideas (what it can't). It pointed to SNAP, WIC and finding a local food bank (where to go), with chips for next steps. A "no" that still gets you somewhere.

Test your 50 hardest prompts before and after launch, and ask each one a few different ways

Phrasing changed the answer. Test your 50 hardest prompts, each a few ways, before and after launch.

Step 4

Make privacy part of the design

Lesson 4: Privacy by design

America.gov's privacy page promises no account, no tracking and no conversations kept. Some answers are cached for up to two hours, it uses an approximate location, and feedback is anonymous. And the product behaves that way: no login required.

Do we really design the product according to our privacy policy that we have laid out on the website?

Upload a PDF and it strips personal details in your browser first, using Rampart, an open-source classifier that detects things like Social Security numbers, phone numbers, emails and card numbers (per Lifehacker). The UI shows "Anonymizing" while it works.

Text PDFs only for now. An image receipt wasn't accepted. The privacy page is also a summary, so read the full policy for retention and logging details.

Step 5

Four ideas to take it further

My four ideas for America.gov, and any AI product that serves people through long, multi-step tasks.

Idea 1: Life events, one timeline, reminders
Idea 2: Skip to the full response
Idea 3: Human handoff with context
Idea 4: Inclusive, open to other AIs

1. Build around life events, not services. One timeline across agencies, with reminders.
2. Let people skip to the full response. Long answers reveal slowly.
3. Human handoff with context. A short summary the person checks and opts in to send to a caseworker.
4. Inclusive by default. More languages, read-aloud, and open to people's own AI assistants through APIs or MCP.

Gut check

Your AI can't help with a question. What should the reply do?

Honest verdict

What to take, and what not to

Use it for
Borrowing four patterns for your own AI product: a prompt library from real questions, visible sources, a four-part "no", and privacy that matches the policy.
Skip it for
Treating it as a final verdict. America.gov is new and still changing, and different phrasings gave me different answers, so what you see may not match mine.
Careful with
The privacy page is a summary. For retention and logging details, read the site's full privacy policy.

Take it to work

Four things to make this week

This week 0 of 4 done

“Email this to myself” opens your own email app with a link back to this cheat sheet. Nothing is sent from this site.

Workflow done.

No streaks and no guilt. Come back whenever you have ten minutes.

The four ideas in detail

Opinions from my walkthrough, not things America.gov has announced.

1. Build around life events

A new baby, or a loved one passing away: administrative tasks that usually mean going through different state and federal agencies. One timeline for everything, so you can see which agency is processing your passport, plus proactive reminders, like a driver licence nudge three months out.

One timeline across agencies, so you can see who is processing your passport right now
Proactive reminders, for example a licence renewal nudge three months out

2. Skip to the full response

The text reveal isn't proportionate to how long a long answer takes. Let people jump to the full response. Claude has a button that skips to the latest message.

3. Human handoff with context

When you save nothing, you have to pay for it. Government tasks take days and involve other people. A short summary the person checks first, then opts in to send to a caseworker, so nobody explains their situation twice. And warn before the tab closes: "This disappears when you leave."

When you save nothing, you have to pay for it

4. Inclusive by default

Open to the AIs people already use, like Claude, Grok or ChatGPT, through APIs or MCP. More languages: it replied in English, French and Spanish, but not Mandarin yet. And a read-aloud button for people who have difficulty seeing.

Have more questions? Ask Chip in the YouTube comments

Sources and credits

An independent review, with thanks to the team behind America.gov.

Also mentioned

Login.gov, Claude, ChatGPT and Grok.

Credits

Thanks to the National Design Studio team behind America.gov: Tai Groot, Caelin, Ahmad Accino, Peter Arnell, Edward Coristine and Joe Gebbia.

Not affiliated

This is an independent review. I'm not affiliated with America.gov or the National Design Studio.

Have more questions? Ask Chip in the YouTube comments